I came across a picture today on Facebook that is titled "The Myth of Trans* Regrets" and is based on a survey from 2011. I know it's a little outdated, but I wanted to provide some personal data. I think there really are a lot of myths out there about what it even means to be trans. There just isn't a lot of information being given out freely. Most people who know about trans people either know someone or they themselves are trans. There's information available, but if you want to find out, you generally have to go and self-educate yourself. Not that it's bad, but it's unfortunate that there isn't enough dialog to give the information in conversation. Here is my list (and responses) of my favorite myths.
1) Being transgender is a choice.
This is anything BUT true. Did you choose to be straight or gay or bisexual? Did you choose to be tall or short? No, it's just who you are; you had no choice in those things.
2) Trans people can't have families.
They may not be able to have biological children post-surgery, but their signifcent other can and they can adopt if they didn't have their own children pre-surgery.
3) Trans people are really just gay.
Not all trans people are gay. But there's nothing saying that after they transition they aren't. Being trans doesn't mean you're gay or straight, it means you identify with the opposite sex and possibly want to have surgery to make everything match.
4) Trans women are all sex workers.
That's absolutely not true. They may be sex workers to pay for their surgery. I've seen a documentary about that, but that doesn't mean they enjoy it. You do what you gotta do to get by. As with any motivated person, people want a career and to make a name for themselves and to provide for their family.
5) All trans people are addicted to sex.
Really? People enjoy sex, that's all there is to it. Not everyone is addicted to sex who enjoys having sex. Do you consider yourself a sex addict?
6) All trans people want surgery.
A lot of people choose not to have both top and bottom surgery. Having your breasts removed or having implants helps one to pass more easily as their identified gender. Bottom surgery isn't necessary, that's more of a personal preference for most trans folks.
7) You aren't a trans person until you start HRT.
Hormon replacement therapy is an important part of transitioning, but I haven't started my HRT yet. Does that mean I'm just deceiving myself and the people I meet? No, I just haven't been able to make HRT fit into my financial scheme.
8) People choose to transition because they were unsuccessful as their birth gender.
I don't know if I am an unsuccessful woman, I just know that I don't identify as a woman.
9) It's just a phase.
Sucking your thumb is just a phase. Living on Ramen noodles is a phase. Trying to reconcile your inside with your outside is anything but a phase.
10) Trans people aren't religious.
There's a church where I live that is all-inclusive. Their mission statement includes everyone under the sun. I may not go to church on a weekly basis, but I've got a relationship with my beliefs and that's enough for me.
11) Conversion therapy is the only cure.
There is no cure. Surgery and HRT isn't a "cure" because it's not a disease. I'm not going to feel like my body matches my mind if I drink enough water and juice and take my vitamins. It's going to require a lifetime of HRT and surgeries. Even then, society will see me as a transsexual. Which is sad, but that's another blog.
12) Being trans is just like being schizophrenic - they are both just hallucinations and delusions, so transition should be prohibited.
I've never heard this before in my life. I don't believe I have separate personalities, but I have sometimes felt like I live two lives. Since changing my name, I don't feel that way anymore.
13) Trans people are deceiving others about their "true" gender.
It's not my goal to deceive anyone. My true gender is that of male. That's who I am, who I'll always be. My body just doesn't match that. Yet.
14) Your sex can be clearly defined by your chromosomes and/or hormones.
Biologically, I am a woman. My chromosomes confirm that. Doesn't mean that I'm a woman.
15) Transgender people are confused.
I was personally most confused about what it was that I was feeling, more than being confused about who I am. I had to figure it out, research it, put a name to it before I could say I wasn't confused.
16) Transitioning ruins lives.
It only ruins your life if you choose to let it ruin your life. Yes, there are people who can't accept that their mom/dad/brother/sister/son/daughter are trans and want to transition. They're the reason things fall apart. If they could be accepting, there could be many more doors of happiness opened for them, and especially for their loved one.
17) Transitioning will make a person bitter and depressed.
I'm not bitter or angry or depressed. Yes, it's a challenging road and I've struggled a lot (and my struggle isn't over yet) but I am a much happier, more confident person because of my honesty and openness about who I really am.
18) Trans people are pressured into having surgery.
Not in the slightest. In fact, I've had friends ask me if I was sure I wanted to have the surgery, if I was sure I wanted to even go on hormones because the side effects are serious. Concern and open dialog is very important in ensuring everyone understands what is entailed in being trans and wanting to transition. I wouldn't say I've been talked out of having surgery, but the concern is genuine and should be appreciated as long as it's not demeaning.
Resources:
"Top Fifty Myths About Being Transgender", democraticunderground.com, Will Parkinson, 2013
"Transgender Visibility Guide: Some Myths and Facts", Human Rights Campaign, 2012
"The Myth of Trans* Regrets", Gender Advocacy Training & Education via Support Equality Rights on facebook.com, 2011